Premier League Stands by VAR Official After Bruno Fernandes Red Card Controversy
Manchester United fans are reeling after Bruno Fernandes received his first-ever red card during the team’s clash with Tottenham Hotspur. Known for his exceptional fitness and leadership, Fernandes now faces an enforced three-match suspension, a scenario that Manchester United is struggling to accept.
The red card incident occurred after Fernandes collided with Tottenham’s James Maddison. Referee Chris Kavanagh immediately brandished the red card, believing it was a clear case of serious foul play. However, Fernandes defended his actions post-match, claiming the foul was accidental. “I slipped, and there was no malice in the challenge,” Fernandes explained, expressing his frustration that the decision wasn’t reviewed more carefully.
While many believed Kavanagh’s on-field decision might be overturned upon review, the Video Assistant Referee (VAR), led by Peter Bankes, upheld the red card decision, determining the play to be serious foul play despite multiple replays suggesting otherwise. The footage clearly showed Fernandes’ studs did not make significant contact with Maddison’s leg, sparking outrage among United fans and pundits alike.
Former Manchester United defender Phil Jones, speaking on Match of the Day 2, criticized the decision. “I am sure it’s not a red card. The initial reaction might suggest it, but when you slow it down, there’s no real studs showing. There’s no malice. I can understand why Kavanagh gave it in real time, but I don’t see why VAR didn’t overturn it. It’s just not a red card.”
Similarly, former referee Mark Halsey voiced his concern, telling The Sun, “The question is why VAR Peter Bankes did not get involved. If VAR had recommended a review, I’m sure Kavanagh would have changed his mind.”
Despite widespread condemnation, the Premier League has opted not to take disciplinary action against Bankes. He has been appointed to referee Manchester City’s upcoming match against Fulham, while Kavanagh will officiate Chelsea’s fixture with Nottingham Forest. This contrasts with previous occasions where officials were demoted following controversial decisions.
United’s next game against Aston Villa will be officiated by Robert Jones, leaving the club and its supporters hoping for better luck in their upcoming fixtures.
Premier League Stands by VAR Official After Bruno Fernandes Red Card Controversy